AWS vs OpenShift: Deploying Container Apps into Cloud

AWS and OpenShift are cloud computing platforms providing various services for organizations. AWS is a comprehensive cloud computing platform offering many services, including computing, storage, and databases. OpenShift, on the other hand, is a platform as a service (PaaS) provided by RedHat & IBM that enables developers to build, test, and deploy container applications on the cloud.

Comparing AWS vs OpenShift isn’t a fair distinction. OpenShift is provided via IBM and Red Hat for container orchestration using Kubernetes. There is actually an OpenShift offering inside of AWS. AWS is a full cloud platform. Better comparisons would be AWS vs IBM or AWS Elastic Kubernetes Service vs Red Hat OpenShift.

Comparison Table of AWS vs OpenShift

Category	AWS	OpenShift
Platform Type	Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS)	Platform as a Service (PaaS)
Pricing Model	Pay-as-you-go, Reserved instances, Spot instances	Subscription-based model
Key Features	Scalability, Security, Flexibility, Reliability	Multi-tenancy, Scalability, Automation, Containerization, Integration
Security	Encryption, Network isolation, Access control	Role-based access control, Network isolation, Secure container runtime environments
Deployment	EC2, Elastic Beanstalk, Lambda, Fargate	Container deployment built on Kubernetes
Scalability	Auto-scaling, Handles larger workloads	Auto-scaling, Built for smaller to medium workloads
Performance	Wide range of tools for optimization, Speed and agility	Limited tools for performance optimization
Use Cases	Web Applications, Big Data, Mobile Applications	DevOps, Microservices, Hybrid Cloud
Cost Effectiveness	Can be more cost-effective for larger workloads	Can be more cost-effective for smaller workloads
Management Tools	AWS Management Console, AWS CloudFormation, AWS CloudTrail	Integrated with various tools like Jenkins, Git, and Kubernetes

Article Highlights

AWS is a comprehensive cloud computing platform known for its scalability, reliability, and security, offering various services, including computing, storage, databases, and a pay-as-you-go pricing model.
OpenShift, a platform as a service (PaaS), is recognized for its flexibility and ease of use, ideal for developers to build, test, and deploy applications swiftly.
The choice between AWS and OpenShift depends on specific needs. AWS offers a more extensive platform, while OpenShift provides a streamlined application development and deployment approach focused on container services like Kubernetes.
AWS offers a range of pricing options, tools, and services to help customers manage their infrastructure, including AWS Management Console, AWS CloudFormation, and AWS CloudTrail.
Key features of AWS include scalability, security, flexibility, and reliability. It provides significant cost savings, increased productivity, global reach, and continuous innovation.
OpenShift, built on Kubernetes, automates the deployment and scaling of containerized applications and supports various programming languages and frameworks.
Key features of OpenShift include multi-tenancy, scalability, automation, containerization, and integration. Benefits include faster time-to-market, greater agility, reduced costs, and greater security.
AWS provides various deployment models, including EC2, Elastic Beanstalk, Lambda, and Fargate, each with benefits and limitations. OpenShift focuses on container deployment, offering different ways to deploy applications.
AWS and OpenShift both deliver high performance, scalability, and security, but AWS has a slight edge in speed, agility, infrastructure size, and extensive security tools.
AWS and OpenShift have different pricing models. AWS charges users based on usage, while OpenShift has a subscription-based model.

Overview of AWS

Amazon Web Services (AWS) is a cloud computing platform that provides a wide range of services to help businesses and individuals build and deploy applications. AWS offers a range of services that can be used for computing, storage, databases, analytics, machine learning, and more. AWS is known for its scalability, reliability, and security.

It offers a variety of pricing options, including pay-as-you-go, reserved instances, and spot instances. The pay-as-you-go option is ideal for businesses needing flexibility and not wanting to commit to a long-term contract.

Reserved instances discount customers willing to commit to a one or three-year contract. Spot instances allow customers to bid on unused EC2 instances and can provide significant cost savings.

AWS also offers a range of tools and services to help customers manage their infrastructure. And AWS Management Console is a web-based interface that allows customers to manage their AWS resources. AWS CloudFormation is a service that helps customers create and manage a collection of related AWS resources.

And AWS CloudTrail is a service that provides a history of AWS API calls for an account, including API calls made through the AWS Management Console, AWS SDKs, command line tools, and other services.

AWS provides a comprehensive set of cloud computing services that can be used to build and deploy applications. AWS offers a variety of pricing options, tools, and services to help customers manage their infrastructure.

Key Features of AWS

AWS (Amazon Web Services) is a cloud computing platform that provides a wide range of services to help businesses and individuals build and deploy applications and services in the cloud.

Some of the key features of AWS include:

Scalability: AWS allows users to scale their infrastructure up or down as needed, depending on their business requirements.
Security: AWS provides a highly secure environment for storing and processing data, with various security features and compliance certifications.
Flexibility: AWS offers a wide range of services and tools that can be used to build and deploy applications across various platforms and devices.
Reliability: AWS has a highly reliable infrastructure, with multiple data centers and backup systems, to ensure that applications and services are always available.

Benefits of AWS

There are many benefits to using AWS for cloud computing, including:

Cost savings: AWS allows users to pay only for the resources they use, which can result in significant cost savings compared to traditional on-premises infrastructure.
Increased productivity: With AWS, users can quickly and easily create and deploy applications and services, which can help to increase productivity and reduce time-to-market.
Global reach: AWS has a global network of data centers, allowing users to deploy applications and services in multiple regions worldwide.
Innovation: AWS is constantly adding new services and features to its platform, which allows users to stay up-to-date with the latest trends and technologies in cloud computing.

AWS is a powerful and flexible platform that can help businesses and individuals build and deploy cloud applications and services. Its wide range of features and benefits makes it a popular choice for many organizations looking to move to the cloud.

Overview of OpenShift

OpenShift is a container application platform designed to streamline containerized applications’ development, deployment, and management. It is an open-source platform built on top of Kubernetes, the popular container orchestration system.

One of the key features of OpenShift is its ability to automate the deployment and scaling of containerized applications. It provides a number of tools and features that make it easy to manage large-scale container deployments, including auto-scaling, load balancing, and rolling updates.

OpenShift also includes a number of built-in security features that help to protect containerized applications from unauthorized access and attacks. These include role-based access control, network isolation, and secure container runtime environments.

Another key benefit of OpenShift is its support for various programming languages and frameworks. Developers can build and deploy applications using popular languages like Java, Python, Node.js, and Ruby and can take advantage of pre-built application templates and libraries.

OpenShift is a powerful and flexible platform that can help organizations to accelerate their container adoption and streamline their application development and deployment processes.

Key Features of OpenShift

OpenShift is a container application platform that allows developers to build, deploy, and manage applications easily.

It provides a variety of features that make it a popular choice for developers, including:

Multi-tenancy: OpenShift allows multiple users to share a single platform while maintaining isolation and security between their applications.
Scalability: OpenShift can scale applications horizontally and vertically to meet changing demands.
Automation: OpenShift automates the deployment and management of applications, reducing the time and effort required from developers.
Containerization: OpenShift uses container technology to package applications and their dependencies, making deploying and managing them easier across different environments.
Integration: OpenShift integrates with various tools and services, such as Jenkins, Git, and Kubernetes, to provide a seamless development and deployment experience.

Benefits of OpenShift

OpenShift offers a number of benefits to developers and organizations, including:

Faster time-to-market: OpenShift’s automation and containerization features allow developers to quickly build, test, and deploy applications, reducing time-to-market.
Greater agility: OpenShift’s scalability and multi-tenancy features allow organizations to respond quickly to changing business needs and scale their applications as required.
Reduced costs: OpenShift’s automation and containerization features help reduce the costs associated with deploying and managing applications, while its multi-tenancy feature allows organizations to share resources more efficiently.
Greater security: OpenShift’s multi-tenancy and containerization features help improve application security by isolating applications and their dependencies from each other and from the underlying infrastructure.

OpenShift is a powerful platform that offers a variety of features and benefits to developers and organizations. Its containerization and automation features make it a popular choice for building and deploying applications, while its scalability and multi-tenancy features help organizations respond quickly to changing business needs.

Deployment Models

AWS: Extensive, Integrated, and Cloud-native

AWS boasts a suite of services for container management and orchestration, each catering to various deployment needs.

Amazon Elastic Kubernetes Service (EKS):
- AWS EKS is a fully managed service that allows you to run Kubernetes on AWS without managing the underlying infrastructure, providing an easy way to deploy, manage, and scale containerized applications using Kubernetes.
Amazon Elastic Container Service (ECS):
- ECS is a high-performance, highly reliable service that allows you to run and manage Docker-enabled applications across a cluster of Amazon EC2 instances.
AWS Fargate:
- For those who prefer to abstract away all the infrastructure management tasks, AWS Fargate is the perfect solution. It lets you deploy containers directly, handling all the orchestration, scaling, and management.
AWS App Runner:
- A service designed for simplicity, allowing quick deployment of containerized applications without the need for any infrastructure management or orchestration setup.

Each of these services is deeply integrated with AWS’s ecosystem, providing a cloud-native approach to container deployment, backed by AWS’s vast infrastructure.

OpenShift: Enterprise-Grade, Self-Managed, and Kubernetes-native

OpenShift, Red Hat’s enterprise Kubernetes platform, offers a different take on container deployment.

Self-managed Kubernetes:
- Unlike AWS’s managed services, OpenShift provides a self-managed Kubernetes platform, giving you more control over your infrastructure and configurations.
Developer-Centric:
- OpenShift provides a developer-centric approach to Kubernetes, with built-in CI/CD pipelines, application monitoring, and logging, making it a comprehensive solution for enterprises looking to adopt DevOps practices.
Multi-cloud and Hybrid Cloud Capabilities:
- OpenShift can run on virtually any infrastructure, be it public cloud, private cloud, or on-premises servers, making it a flexible choice for hybrid or multi-cloud deployments.
Integrated DevSecOps:
- With built-in security features and the ability to integrate with a multitude of third-party security solutions, OpenShift provides a solid foundation for DevSecOps practices.

In a nutshell, AWS provides a more cloud-native, integrated approach with a variety of managed services to cater to different needs. On the flip side, OpenShift provides a self-managed, enterprise-grade Kubernetes platform with a focus on developer experiences and hybrid cloud deployments. Your choice would hinge on your team’s expertise, the level of control you desire over the environment, and your infrastructure preferences.

The comparison elucidates the essence of both platforms—AWS aligning more with cloud-native deployments with various degrees of management, and OpenShift leaning towards enterprises with complex, multi-cloud, or on-premises environments demanding a higher degree of control and robust DevOps practices..

Comparative Analysis

Performance

AWS and OpenShift can deliver high performance, but AWS has a slight edge over OpenShift in terms of speed and agility. AWS offers a wide range of services that can be used to optimize performance, such as Amazon Elastic Compute Cloud (EC2), Amazon Simple Storage Service (S3), and Amazon CloudFront. OpenShift, on the other hand, has a more limited set of tools for performance optimization.

Scalability

Both AWS and OpenShift are highly scalable, but AWS has a more extensive infrastructure and can handle larger workloads. AWS offers auto-scaling, allowing users to adjust resources based on demand. OpenShift also has auto-scaling capabilities but is not as robust as AWS.

Security

Security is a top priority for both AWS and OpenShift. AWS has many security features, including encryption, network isolation, and access control. OpenShift also offers security features, such as role-based access control and container security. However, AWS has a more extensive set of tools for security and compliance.

Cost

AWS and OpenShift have different pricing models. And AWS charges users based on usage, while OpenShift has a subscription-based model. AWS can be more expensive for small workloads, but it can be more cost-effective for larger workloads. OpenShift can be more cost-effective for smaller workloads but may not be as cost-effective for larger workloads.

Both AWS and OpenShift have their strengths and weaknesses. It is important to evaluate the organisation’s specific needs to determine which platform is best suited for their needs.

Use Cases

Use Cases for AWS

AWS is a cloud computing platform that provides its users with a wide range of services.

Here are some use cases for AWS:

Web Applications: AWS is an ideal platform for hosting web applications. It provides a scalable, flexible infrastructure that can handle traffic spikes and deliver high performance.
Big Data: AWS provides various services for big data processing and analytics. Users can store and process large amounts of data using services like Amazon S3, Amazon Redshift, and Amazon EMR.
Mobile Applications: AWS provides various services for mobile application development and hosting. Developers can use services like Amazon API Gateway, AWS Lambda, and Amazon SNS to build and deploy mobile applications.

Use Cases for OpenShift

OpenShift is a container application platform that allows users to deploy and manage applications in the cloud.

Here are some use cases for OpenShift:

DevOps: OpenShift provides a platform for DevOps teams to build, test, and deploy applications. It provides automation tools that streamline the development process and improve collaboration between developers and operations teams.
Microservices: OpenShift is an ideal platform for building and deploying microservices-based applications. It provides a container-based architecture that allows developers to build and deploy applications modular and scalable.
Hybrid Cloud: OpenShift provides a platform for building and deploying applications across multiple cloud environments. Users can deploy applications on-premise, in the cloud, or a hybrid environment, depending on their needs.

AWS and OpenShift are powerful cloud computing platforms offering their users a wide range of services. The choice between them depends on the user’s specific needs and the application type they are building.

AWS vs OpenShift: Comparing Two Popular Cloud Platforms Summary

In summary, AWS and OpenShift are powerful platforms with unique strengths and weaknesses. It also isn’t a 1 to 1 comparison. OpenShift is focused primarily on containers & Kubernetes whereas AWS is a full cloud platform. A better comparison would be RedHat OpenShift vs AWS Elastic Kubernetes Service.

AWS is the more established and widely used platform, offering many services and features. It is particularly well-suited for large-scale enterprises with complex needs and high-volume workloads. AWS also has a strong reputation for reliability and scalability, making it a popular choice for mission-critical applications.

On the other hand, OpenShift is a newer platform gaining popularity among developers due to its ease of use and flexibility. It is built on top of Kubernetes and provided by IBM through Red Hat, which gives it a strong foundation for container orchestration. OpenShift also offers a range of tools for building and deploying applications, making it a great choice for agile development teams.

Regarding pricing, AWS is known for being expensive, especially for smaller businesses or startups. OpenShift, on the other hand, offers a more affordable pricing model based on usage, making it a more accessible option for businesses of all sizes.

Ultimately, the choice between AWS and OpenShift will depend on each organization’s specific needs and goals. Both platforms have unique strengths and weaknesses, and it is important to carefully evaluate each before deciding.

Cloud Hosting Article Series

This article is part of our series on cloud hosting for your web applications. Check out the following articles to dig further into your options.